A troubleshooter who suspects a design limitation should check the columns hydraulic performance. Tray Distillation Columns Efficiency, Flooding & Weeping When flooding starts on a tray, all the trays above that point will also flood, but trays below that point will go dry . This The trouble-shooter decided to inspect the tower. Entrainment Back-mixing via liquid entrainment reduces efficiency. Restrictions Blockage of the flow area under a downcomer will back up liquid. The function of a tray is to mix the vapor and liquid together to form foam. separation zones are used instead of plates or trays. Further consequence of the excessive pressure drop created from the high weir loading could be downcomer back-up or choke flooding. To minimize scaling and facilitate cleaning, the decision was made to replace the valve trays with stainless-steel sieve trays. Increase the columns tray spacing: Increasing the tray spacing on the column can reduce weeping by increasing the distance through which the vapor and liquid must pass, thus reducing the chance of weeps. In a packed column the liquid is intended to flow downwards across the entire cross section of the column, so weeping is not a relevant concept in a packed column. On the negative side, the capacity of a column equipped with bubble-cap trays is generally about 15% less per unit transfer area than that of a column having sieve or valve trays, because the height of the bubble caps makes the tray spacing narrower. Analyze the compositions of the overhead and bottoms streams to determine the separation efficiency. Liquid flowrates higher than 12 gal/ min per inch of outlet weir increase the liquid crest over the weir, adding to the liquid level on the tray. where crest height = inches of the level of clear liquid overflowing the outlet weir; GPM = gallons (U.S.) per minute of liquid that leaves from the tray. Uneven distribution As does liquid bypassing, poor liquid distribution undermines liquid and vapor contacting. The factor that compensates aeration effect is 0.5. the feedpipe was turned so that the discharge orifices were on top of the pipe; this ensured that the sparger remained full of liquid at low feedrates; additionally, a deflector bar was installed above the orifices to keep feed from impinging on the tray above. If the downcomer clearance (the distance between the bottom edge of the downcomer and the tray below) is too large, the downcomer becomes unsealed. written clearly. Equipment and Operation, Column If the vapor rate is too low the 4. The liquid starts overflowing the outlet weir and drains through the downcomer to the tray below. Only reducing the boUup rate to a fraction of design rate kept the tower stable. The two effects normally cancel each other, and efficiency is practically independent of load changes (assuming no excessive entrainment or weeping). Tray flooding is often differentiated into jet flooding and downcomer flooding. dideo The outlet zone extends from the last row of contactors to the outlet weir. Check that the cooling and heating systems are operating correctly. Corrective action: One solution might have been to i plug some of the orifices to raise the discharge velocity to j several ft/s. Typically, the distillation tower does not stand alone; it is usually connected to upstream and downstream equipment that, together, make up a comprehensive process system. The initial horizontal run of gravity sidedraw piping should be free of valves or other flow restriction. , Reorinted from CHEMICAL ENGINEERING Mau 10S0 mnuhi ioao hu i ,.., *m, Continue reading here: Vapor Blanketing Reboiler Corrective Actions. laboratory work most of time the distillation column will work with a total reflux, i.e., the entire vapor at the top of the column is condensed. Opening the column revealed that the top few valve trays were coated with a 1-inch thick layer of black crystalline material, which analysis established to be mostly iron. The design of the distillation column is critical to unit performance, size, and cost. Weeping is undesirable and the liquid should flow across the tray and down the downcomer. limiting condition occurs at minimum reflux Monitor temperature and pressure readings to ensure that the operating conditions remain within the specified range. 0000000711 00000 n
An entrainment-induced loss of efficiency can occur well below the flooding rate if the entrainment is high relative to the flow of liquid across the tray. A plait point is the point on the solubility curve, where the tie line reduces to a point. This is one of the most common terms related to welding for joining two metal pieces together to get a permanent joint. Sidedraw piping must be sized for self-venting and the gravity flow of saturated liquid, to avoid flashing in the line. The flow regime associated with flooding generates more high frequency white noise, which can be detected in the DP signal across the column. Whether flooding starts in the transfer area or in the downcomer will depend on which area is limiting. You would use simple distillation when the two products you are Weeping is indicated by a sharp pressure drop in the column and reduced separation efficiency. Height Of Packed Bed Co2 Stripping Column, Heat Transfer Coefficient Of The Packed Bed Student, This is not recommended for shared computers. This differs from what occurs in the packed column, where the wetted packing provides much of the surface area for mass transfer. This back mixing of liquid causes the reduction of separation, mass transfer, or efficiency of the tray of a distillation tower. and this lowers its density, increasing the liquid height in the downcomer above that equivalent to the clear liquid head. The drawings revealed the following: the flow from reboiler jetted directly into the ; seal pan; an inlet weir had been placed on the feed tray; the ! This turndown ratio can be increased by reducing the fractional hole area. Weeping determines the minimum vapour flow required while flooding determines the maximum vapour flow allowed, hence column capacity. Outcome: The hydraulic hammer was eliminated. 2023 Copyright COSTELLO. The duty of the reboiler increases to regain the bottom temperature of the distillation tower to its set point. 0000005062 00000 n
Stability of the column may become an issue. On Suggest three (3) possible steps that can improve the efficiency and solve the problems . Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links. order to separate them by evaluating the boiling point, simple distillation is separation of material depending upon (This same pressure drop exists across the downcomer.) Troubleshooting Process Operations by Norman Lieberman. The closest analogous concepts for packed columns would be mal-distribution (as you have suggested) or wetting rate. The distillation process is used to separate components based on their boiling points. Sieve trays have a low turndown ratio of about 2. HETP packing. Distillation columns are the primary equipment used in the chemical process industry to carry out the separation of organic chemicals. If any of the foregoing contributors level on the j becomes excessive (for instance, too tray be- > much head loss under the downcomer or aeration due to foaming), liquid will back up in the downcomer and spill onto the tray. Thus, on one tray, liquid flows from two siae-downcomers to a center downcomer: on the next tray (up or down), liquid from the center down-comer splits into flows to both of the side-downcomers. Make sure the condenser is operating efficiently and the condensate is being removed quickly. The most common tray-column vapor-and-liquid contactors are sieve, valve and bubble-cap trays. The height of the foam resides on the tray, The velocity of the vapor through the tray, DP = pressure drop across a tray section, psi, s.g. = specific gravity of the clear liquid, at flowing temperatures. An excessive liquid gradient causes severe malfunctioning of the tray as most of the gas flows through the holes near the middle of the tray and at the outlet weir section (where the effective liquid depth on the tray is low) and only a small part of flows through the holes at the liquid inlet side of the tray. In a trayed column, these flow areas are fixed by how the design engineer allocates downcomer and transfer area. The equivalent clear liquid level on a tray below, which is influenced by its outlet weir height and the weir's crest of flowing liquid, generates a "static" liquid backup into the downcomer. But for the bubble cap tray, it may be significant because the bubble caps offer a larger resistance to liquid flow. This type of tray is less expensive than others, but. Install a reboiler cooler: A reboiler cooler can help reduce or control weeping by cooling the liquid going into the reboiler. This will not have any impact on the foam height on the tray deck until the downcomer fills with liquid foam. Once tray-2 floods, downcomer C (shown in Fig. A check of the design drawings indicated that the feedpipe and feed sparger might be somewhat oversized, especially at the 30% feed rate. Inc.*. ' As one of the most expensive and energy-consuming units in a plant, the fluid dynamics of the . Affecting Operation, Other is rarely used because of low efficiencies and limited operating flexibility-. . Then a further increment of vapor flow causes a significant increase in the foam height of the tray of the distillation tower, which increases the height of the spray section. The bubble cap's more-positive liquid trapping confers good operating-rate. WBbM42v\nuuaTT @. Check the condenser and reboiler systems for any potential fouling. This dimension should be carefully checked by process personnel when a tower is opened for inspection. Excessive weeping will lead to dumping. The distillation column is a key component of ammonia-water absorption units including advanced generator-absorber heat exchange (GAX) cycle heat pumps. Learn Industrial Distillation from Industry ExpertComplete Understanding of Design, Operation, Troubleshooting and Optimization of industrial distillation column.Rating: 4.5 out of 515 reviews10 total hours55 lecturesAll LevelsCurrent price: $14.99Original price: $24.99. Adjust the reflux ratio and/or other operating conditions to optimize performance. Contact Us Design your distillation scheme with Aspen Distillation Synthesis. Excess loading, fouled trays, restricted transfer area and poor vapor distribution, improper feedpipe and tray installation. Restricted transfer area Poor vapor distribution across a tray can result in local areas of high entrainment, and initiate jet flooding. The 0000000016 00000 n
The driving force that causes this entrainment is the vapor flow through the distillation tower. In the Hi There! A tray consists of a liquid-inlet, a heat-and-mass-transfer. This may be limited by the allowable pressure drop specified for the. The AIChE online library includes articles, journals, books, blog posts, and more on a variety of topics. Columns distilling hydrocarbons often operate at Murphree efficiencies near to, or above, 100%. Vapor passing through the perforated plate forms a two-phase mixture with the liquid and enables mass transfer contacting. As in a packed column, gravity is the driving force for liquid downflow. downcomer clearance specified was more than j adequate); and a reboiler overflow weir had been raised to within seven inches of the reboiler return nozzle, and this was possibly limiting the disengagement space. 0000001598 00000 n
It causes the mixing of the entrained liquid from the lower tray with the liquid on the upper tray. Improper feed introduction Vapor or flashing feeds that enter into or above downcomers can promote flooding. It is occasionally used in vacuum columns to iower the tray pressure drop by reducing the height of the liquid crest over the outlet weir. Weeping is caused due to low vapor velocity. Weeping is undesirable and the liquid should flow across the tray and down the downcomer. This helps to reduce the disengagement load of the downcomer and often lessens the tendency of the outlet row of contactors to blow liquid over the outlet weir into the downcomer. Liquid Equilibria, Distillation As per the figure depicted in Fig.1A, it has been clearly shown that downcomer B is flooding. i dont think there will be anycorrelation for calculating channelling in the packed bed but in order to avoid it you have to restrict the packing bedheight. Select the operating conditions: batch or continuous; operating pressure. At each turnaround, the trays had to be cleaned, a difficult and time-consuming task. Then vapor flows up the downcomer, and flooding occurs. lowing: mats left from the previous entry into the column, fallen panels from upper trays, dislocated baffles, or forgotten blanking strips installed to prevent weeping during a previous low-rate operation. Since about the 1950s, sieve and valve trays have virtually displaced bubble-cap trays, which are more expensive and offer lower capacity. Common is a downcomer panel installed so as to limit the liquid outlet clearance r, FIGURE 10. This may be caused by damaged or poorly assembled tray panels that allow excessive weeping. This flow can hinder the flow of liquid into a downcomer or cause excessive aeration. weir height and clearance under the downcomer had been j lowered to provide greater turndown (calculations indicated the 1-in. It is the top section of the distillation column. Types of contactors The most common tray-columnvapor-and-liquid contactors are sieve, valve and bubble-cap trays. All Rights Reserved, FACTORS AFFECTING DISTILLATION COLUMN OPERATION, Types As the liquid height on a tray increases, the height of liquid present in the downcomer that is fed to this tray will increase by the same amount. ing or hiking the tray pressure drop and backing up liquid into the next higher downcomer. reaction-followed-by-distillation processes [2,12,13,17,54]. zAn early indication of flooding in a distillation column is loss of liquid level in the bottom of the column. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. The bottom product continued to meet specifi-1 cations, suggesting that the flooding was starting near the top of the column. Bottom seal-pan Difficulties arise with the downcomer from the bottom tray and its seal pan. The height of the crest is similar to the height of water overflowing a dam or a river. The downcomer typically takes up a segment of a column's diameter but can be a pipe, box or other shape. p. 116. Excessive vapor flow through the downcomer could reduce its ability to deaer-ate liquid flowing into it. Raising the reflux only a little made the column unstable. Engineered distributors are designed for a specific range of liquid flows. Valve trays offer about the same capacity and efficiency as sieve trays, but i tend to weep less. Consequently, sieve trays are most of ten used when turndown is not critical, i Valve trays represent a compromise I between bubble-cap ana sieve trays, i providing greater operating flexibility i at a cost only slightly higher (Figure 6). Figure 7. Save my name and email in this browser for the next time I comment. Valve trays (such aa the four-pass one shown upper left) represent a compromise between the bubble-cap and sieve trays. ' Packing is evenly distributed throughout the column FIGURE 10. a tray efficiency of 70% and a 21-in. If the nozzle is located closer to the lower tray, the entering vapor may interfere with the mass of liquid and vapor above the tray. This signifies that if we calculate a level of clear liquid of 12 inches in the downcomer, then the actual level of foam in the downcomer is 12 inches/(0.50) = 24 inches of foam. As vapor velocity is not enough, vapors will not pass through tray holes, moreover vapors will pass through gap between tray and column. of Columns, Basic In Packed column you have channelling (liquid flows alongthe wall of the column after traveling certain height of packed bed)and in tray column you have weeping (vapour flow rate becomes insufficient to hold the liquid on tray). High liquid gradients across bubble-cap trays will distribute vapor flow disproportionately toward the outlet side. Valve trays normally have a turndown ratio of 4 while bubble cap trays have a still larger turndown ratio. For trays of the distillation tower, the incipient flood point corresponds to the best efficiency point. The head loss caused bv the liquid flowing through the restricted space between the bottom of the downcomer panel and the seal pan also contributes to where the level is in a downcomer. zIf the downcomer clearance-which means the distance Manage Settings Provides large interfacial surface for mass transfer. to ensure that vapor will not enter the downcomer. Reply. Unexpected foaming will excessively aerate ! Flooding detected without such signs of lost efficiency or a sudden steep rise in pressure drop indicates downcomer flooding (Figure 8). This will ensure that the flooding point of the column is not reached. However, to keep velocities below 6 ft/s at j design feed rates, the following remedy was implemented: ! For this reason, such trays or downcomers are often designed with internal overflow protection. A high liquid level in the column base will cause liquid to back up into this downcomer. rate rising nonlinearly before signs of flooding appear (indicating a higher rate is required for efficient separation) suggests a loss of efficiency from liquid entrainment prior to jet flooding. Incorrectly interchanged tray panels of different design can increase vapor velocities, pressure drop and entrainment. Most other tray types represent a modification of the sieve, valve or bubble-cap tray. Jet flooding results from more energy being transferred from the entering vapor into the liquid on a tray than can be dissipated in the space above the tray. Use tray protectors to reduce the risk of flooding. Because its violent method of generating mass-transfer area (compared with ; the packed column) occurs at the expense of pressure drop energy, a trayed column operates at a higher pressure drop per stage than does a packed columns. Only an inspection disclosed the problem: The case of the top-flooding column. A higher level raises the tray pressure drop and boosts the tendency of liquid weeping through the vapor flow openings. Holes or orifices, typically lA in. However. Increase the reflux ratio: Increasing the reflux ratio can allow the top section of the column to be cooler, helping to reduce weeping. Suspecting a problem with downcomers in the j rectifying section, the troubleshooter checked to see if the design tray pressure drop could be a significant contributor to downcomer backup, and found the pressure drops to be reasonable. liquid may be able to drop to the next stage through the holes, The remainder of the tray is active in contacting vapor and liquid. Loss of liquid level in the bottom of the column is an early indication of flooding in a distillation column. Monitor the temperature of the column and make sure it is maintained within the specified range. There is no reliable method of predicting efficiency. The performance of a given distillation column depends on many factors, for example, . volatality. At lower flow-rates. Tray pressure drops range from 2Vi to 8 mm Hg, depending considerably on I the liquid and vapor loadings, tray type, ; outlet weir height, and design pres- j sure-drop limitations. Liquid starts backing up in the downcomer if the downcomer clearance is too small, and the trays above become flooded. If the column is limited by flooding or pressure drop to a feedrate close to the designated column capacity, the troubleshooter should evaluate the column's hydraulic performance by means of available correlations. The reduction in distillation tray efficiency caused by uniform weeping of liquid from the tray has been calculated. The onset of distillation column flooding is associated with a change in the flow regimes of the gas and liquids flowing inside the column. If a very small fraction of the liquid flows from a tray to the lower one through perforation or openings of the tray deck, the phenomenon is called weeping. In distillation column, liquid flows in downward direction by gravitational force but it flows against the pressure. pan to minimize the chance of the downcomer panel being incorrectly installed or dislocated. This means that, at zero cost to you, I will earn an affiliate commission if you click through the link and finalize a purchase. This sensitivity to liquid rate suggested a liquid flow-path problem, such as downcomer flooding. 375 0 obj<>
endobj
When flooding commences on a tray, all the trays above the flooding point will also be flooded, but trays below that point will get dried up.